• Are Your IP Costs Too High?
  • Need Help Finding The Right Strategic Relationship?
  • Need Help Negotiating a License?
  • Looking for a Partner?
  • Do You Know What Your Competition Is Up To?
  • Are You Using Your IP Effectively?


While researching examples of interesting patents, I came across the picture of one of the earliest flight simulators. Being an avid sailplane enthusiast, I couldn’t resist further investigation. I found that this drawing was created in 1917 in support of a German patent application that was filed in the United States in 1919 and entitled:

US1402498-Fig3“Device for Training Pilots and Observers in Handling Aeroplanes”

It describes suspending an entire bi-plane in a gimbal to permit movement along all three axis’. Using the backwash from the engine’s propeller as motive force, the pilot would actuate the flight surfaces and cause the airplane to yaw and pitch. Below the contraption, support personnel would unfurl a map at various speeds simulating different altitudes and to render a more realistic experience to the pilot. This training device was used to help pilots familiarize themselves with targeting objects on the ground with their fuselage mounted guns as well as observers to get their timing correct while dropping bombs from varying ‘heights’. All-in-all, quite ingenious….

Why is this relevant? Sailplanes have minimal instrumentation and are really fly-by-the-seat-of-your-pants aircraft. When coming in for a landing, many times of which may not be desirable or predictable (remember that sailplanes don’t have any engines and remain up only by the ability of the pilot to harness the sun’s energy for lift), you are judging your landing in a farmer’s field by using your Mark 1 Eyeball – getting the distance and height correct is absolutely vital to walking away unharmed and being able to use your aircraft for another flight! There are no go-arounds unlike in a powered aircraft.

For those of you interested to learn more about soaring and sailplanes, I encourage to visit my club’s website -> Windy City Soaring Association. We are open April through November and provide demonstration rides to the public.

US1402498_Device for training pilots and observers in handling aeroplanes.



Contact Us

Licensing & IP Solutions Associates, Inc.
Tel: +1 (630) 797-5021 | Email

Mike has successfully led Motorola Solutions’ intellectual property strategy and is a very skilled technology and patent licensing professional. He has been instrumental in forging Motorola’s core IP focus by providing mentorship and direction to the senior executive team and business leaders. Mike is well versed in all aspects of IP assessment, business modeling and valuation, standards and negotiations. He’s detail-oriented, objective and able to help drive an effective IP strategy to meet the goals of the business. Mike is a true business leader who would be an asset to any organization
Wayne Partington
VP of Business Development
Motorola Solutions